Stuck Between a Gas or Charcoal Grill? Which Is The Best BBQ?
Which is better - a gas grill or a charcoal grill? This question is actually one of the most controversial discussions in the grilling world! And we’re here to help clear the air a bit.
After all, one really isn’t better than the other!
The best BBQ is less about the perfect cooking conditions and more about each grill master’s preferences.
A charcoal grill might give a smokier flavour, but a gas grill allows you to savour the natural taste of meat.
If you prefer a smoky-tasting steak, then a charcoal grill is probably the best BBQ for your personal taste preferences. But if the natural taste of meat is something you prefer, then a gas grill might better suit you.
Are you a seasoned griller or new to the trade? Whether you’ve been grilling for years or are about to buy your first barbeque, we have one of the best grill selections in Sudbury!
Everyone has their own grilling preferences. All you have to do is find your must-have tool of the trade!
What Features Should You Look For In a New Barbeque?
At Campeau Heating, we always recommend a Napoleon BBQ. But whether that’s a gas barbeque or charcoal barbeque is entirely up to you!
Let’s explore what makes both options unique.
How long does it take a barbeque to heat up?
If you barbeque quick weeknight meals for your family all summer long, then the heat-up time of your grill might be the most crucial factor to consider.
However, if grilling is a passion or something you only do on the weekends, you might not mind waiting!
Charcoal Grill Heat-Up Time: 15-30 minutes
A charcoal BBQ can take up to 30 minutes to preheat. And that doesn’t include the time it takes to ignite the charcoal either, which can add an additional 15 minutes to your prep time.
Gas Grill Heat-Up Time: 10 minutes
A gas BBQ only takes 10 minutes to heat up. And with instant ignition capabilities, you’re ready to start grilling in under 15 minutes! Plus, this quick preheat on your cooking grates gives fantastic sear marks!
The cooking power of your barbeque tells you how hot your grill can get.
The higher the heat, the hotter your grill can get. The hotter the grill gets, the faster you’ll be able to cook!
Although some grillers prefer a slow sear, others prefer a quick meal. And if you plan to host backyard patios with lots of hungry guests, a powerful barbeque with a high heat capacity could mean the difference between dinner at 7 PM and dinner at 10 PM.
Charcoal Grill Cooking Power: Usually up to 1200 degrees Fahrenheit
Gas Grill Cooking Power: Usually up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit
The temperature control of your barbeque is what gives you the best control over your cooking.
If you’re a seasoned griller, temperature control might not worry you. But if you’ve never done it before, looking for a grill with a set-it-and-forget-it type of temperature control might be your best option.
Charcoal Grill Temperature Control:
With a charcoal barbeque, you will need some practice and patience when learning to maintain a consistent cooking temperature. Because you are working with varying coals - each with a different size, shape and burning time - temperature control is quite difficult.
Gas Grill Temperature Control:
A gas barbeque can easily maintain a steady heat level and distribute that heat evenly across the grill.
The versatility of your grill can add incredible (and yummy) diversity to your menu.
For example, if your barbeque has direct infrared and indirect heat, your cooking options are endless. You can bake, smoke, sear or grill!
Some barbeques also come with multiple different burners and even rotisserie kits!
Charcoal Grill Versatility:
A charcoal barbeque can have direct and indirect cooking areas.
Gas Grill Versatility:
A gas barbeque can have multiple burners, accessories and kits.
Health and Safety
When selecting a barbeque for your backyard, one of your first instincts will be to check whether this appliance is safe for you, your family and your home.
Charcoal Grill Health and Safety:
- The lack of temperature control could become a safety risk.
- The lighter fluid could cause health risks.
Gas Grill Health and Safety:
Cleanup and Maintenance
It’s easy to get caught up in the cooking aspects of your barbeque and forget about the cleanup and maintenance factors.
Charcoal Grill Clean-Up:
A charcoal barbeque requires routine maintenance, regular ash disposal, and grate cleaning.
Gas Grill Clean-Up:
A gas barbeque requires:
- Routine maintenance
- A routine check on the propane tank or gas line.
- A regular cleaning of the grill grates, drip pan and flavour bars.
Lastly, the cost is a huge consideration when selecting a new barbeque.
Charcoal Grill Cost: Less Expensive
Gas Grill Cost: More Expensive
- A gas barbeque is much pricier - ranging from $500-1500. With advanced features, they can even go as high as $2,000!
Shop Our Napoleon Barbeque Line at Campeau Heating
See Our Selection
Are you ready to expand your kitchen skills outdoors with our incredible Napoleonoutdoor products? Get in touch with our Campeau Heating team today to find the best BBQ for your backyard grill!
Our Napoleon Gas Grill Line
- Napoleon Prestige PRO Series Gas Grills
- Napoleon Gas Grill - Prestige Series
- Napoleon Rogue SE Series
- Napoleon Rogue Series
Our Napoleon Charcoal Grill Line
- Napoleon Charcoal Grills
- Napoleon Apollo Series
Get Ready For Summer Grilling With Campeau Heating in Sudbury, Ontario!
Get your BBQ apron on and grab a flipper - Summer is almost here!
Still not sure which barbeque suits your cooking style, budget and taste? We are here to help!
You can reach out to our Campeau Heating team at 705-560-2441 or contact us online!